Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Highways and Hedges Part 4 - Holiness And Pentecostal Freewill Baptists

Introduction

It has been a while since I have done an installment on the "Highways and Hedges" project due to graduate school and some other factors.  However, this one promises to be interesting, as it is dealing with a family of churches that I have been intrigued by for some time.   My mother initially piqued my interest in Pentecostal Freewill Baptists as she was discipled by a Freewill Baptist couple with Pentecostal convictions when she was in the military in Okinawa back in the 1960's.  When I really began to study Church History in the latter part of my high school years, I came across an actual group called "Pentecostal Freewill Baptists" and upon inquiring, I got a rather large package of material from their denominational headquarters in Dunn, NC.  Later, when I eventually received the Pentecostal baptism of the Holy Spirit myself in 1989, I briefly affilliated with this group and almost was ordained by them, but of course God had other plans.  Nonetheless, my involvement in the earlier part of my Christian life with both Baptists and Pentecostals still drove me to research this further, and come to find out, there are actually several Freewill Baptist fellowships that are openly Pentecostal, as well as one that is closely identified with the Keswick movement.  In this article, I will be dealing with five of those smaller groups.  Being the Dunn-based Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church is a large nationwide group of over 10,000 members, it will not qualify for attention in this study except for some valuable reference material as it relates to the other groups.  The five groups I am going to focus on, however, are all small regional fellowships for the most part with small memberships, but they still have a fascinating heritage.  It is my hope that these, like so many of the groups we have already examined, will be taken seriously as oftentimes it is small fellowships like them which have the most valuable historical merit.

The way I will be organizing this particular article is actually quite simple.  First, I feel like a brief background of Freewill Baptist history will set the stage, and also I want to give a brief background of the Holiness/Pentecostal movement as it occurred in the Piedmont Carolinas, as it is integral to the story.  The information I am presenting here took a lot of work to find, and to be honest almost 20 years of continuous research as some information on these smaller fellowships was hard to come by.  In many cases, letters written were unanswered, phone numbers were out-of-service, and the internet didn't provide sufficient information on some groups like I needed.  Therefore, I had to resort to databases like GoogleMaps and Lexis/Nexis in many cases to dig up some of it.  This is why I am hoping a project like this will be beneficial to others. 

Therefore let us now begin with a brief historical overview of the parent movements that produced the smaller fellowships.

Historical Background

The history of many of these movements, in particular the North Carolina churches, has two components.  First, they are of Free Will Baptist heritage, so we will give a brief overview of that.  Secondly, all of the Carolina groups in particular are Pentecostals as well, and therefore the Holiness/Pentecostal movement in the Carolinas merits a brief discussion, particularly the evangelist G.B. Cashwell's revival meetings around the Dunn, NC, area in the early 1900's.  The Ohio group, the Christian Baptist Churches of God, is a result of a Keswick/Higher Life influence on the Free Will and Regular Baptists in the state, and thus it is non-Pentecostal but still unique enough to warrant attention in this study.  

A.  Free Will Baptists - A Brief History

The Free Will Baptists begin their history in 16th-century England with a group of Protestant Separatists who formed a congregation at Gainsbourough-on-Trent in 1606.  In 1610, a group led by Thomas Helwys separated from the Gainsborough group when John Smyth led a portion of that congregation into union with Dutch Mennonites around 1615 or so.   These became what was known as "General Baptists," as opposed to the Calvinistic Particular Baptists, and they were called "General" because they were Arminian in doctrine (Alfred W. Wardin, Baptist Atlas {Nashville: Broadman, 1980} pp. 6-7).  General Baptists soon consisted of several groups, including the General Six-Principle Baptists, who in 1652 formed their first American congregations.  The important aspect of this study, however, comes with the settlement of one General Baptist preacher, Paul Palmer, in 1727 in the Chowan Precinct of North Carolina.

Palmer is generally credited with being the "father of the Free Will Baptist Church" in North Carolina, and his contribution to that heritage can still be seen today among many Free Will Baptist denominations in the region.  In the early 1800's, many of the General Baptist congregations owing their heritage to Palmer were often dubbed by their detractors with the name "Free Willers," and in 1828 they took the name for their own, calling themselves from that point "Free Will Baptists" (Michael Pelt, "Original Free Will Baptist History," accessed from issuu.com/ofwb/docs/original_free_will_baptist_history‎, page 2).  They found a fertile area for growth in eastern North Carolina, which is still a Free Will Baptist stronghold even today, and in time a number of fellowships of these Free Will Baptists would evolve.   In the early 1900's, a move to unify the growing national Free Will Baptist constituency resulted in the creation of what today is known as the National Association of Free Will Baptists, headquartered currently in Nashville.  However, many of the older North Carolina churches were opposed to much of this centralization, and wanted to keep things less structured, which resulted in the formation in 1913 of the Original Free Will Baptist Convention, which formally split from the National Association in 1961 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_Free_Will_Baptist_Convention - accessed 8/26/2013).  Although not formally organized until 1961, the Original Free Will Baptists did have an influence, and it is from them that many of the Pentecostal groups would actually form later.

Little Creek Free Will Baptist Church, Ayden, NC - the oldest existing Free Will Baptist congregation in the state, established 1756 (photo courtesy of Mount Olive College)
 
 
The evolution of the Pentecostal groups from the Original Free Will Convention is largely contingent upon the formation of three North Carolina conferences - Cape Fear (1855), New River, and Wilmington.  The Cape Fear Conference, upon further research, started out as Original Free Will Baptist until they parted ways in 1912 after adopting Holiness/Pentecostal belief when they reorganized as the Cape Fear Conference of the Free Will Baptist Holiness Churches.  These three, along with a group of South Carolina Free Will Baptists who similarly adopted Pentecostalism, became the nucleus of what evolved into the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church, which was formally organized in 1959 (Gary M. Bailey, "A History of the Division Between the Original Free Will Baptists and Pentecostal Free Will Baptists" {non-published, 1992} p. 4-6).   However, the South Carolina Conference eventually bowed out of that merger, and exists today as a separate denomination, the Free Will Baptist Conference of Pentecostal Faith, which we will be talking more in detail about later.  

The Stony Run Church in Dunn, NC, where the Cape Fear Original Free Will Baptist Conference was organized in 1855 (it is now part of the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church)

A this point we now turn attention to developments in Ohio.  According to researched sources, the first Free Will Baptist Church in Ohio was called the Old Kyger Church, and it was founded in the year 1805 in Cheshire, OH.  Ohio, much like the Carolinas, was impacted greatly by religious diversity, and Free Will Baptists found fertile ground for growth in particular in the southeastern region of the state.  The area around Scioto County is particularly of interest to this study, as it was here that our focal church movement, the Christian Baptist Churches of God, evolved from the Scioto Yearly Meeting of Free Will Baptists, which was organized largely through the efforts of Rev. Rufus Cheney (1780-1869) (Loveless, McComas, and Hayes, Great Is Thy Faithfulness - Over 200 Years of Ohio Free Will Baptist History, 1805-2009 {Reynoldsburg, OH: Ohio State Association of Free Will Baptists, 2009} pp. 7-8).  Thus, the Free Will Baptist history of Ohio as relates to this study.

Rev. Rufus Cheney (1780-1869), pioneer Free Will Baptist minister in southeastern Ohio
 
Now that we have briefly examined the Free Will Baptist story, let us now proceed to the second aspect of the heritage of many of these groups, which is the Pentecostal movement.
 
The Holiness/Pentecostal Movement in North Carolina
 
North Carolina has always had a diverse religious landscape, ranging from Free Will Baptists in the eastern part of the state to German-speaking Moravians in the foothills of the Smokies in the West.   The impact of the Awakenings and other religious revivals made the area a prime location for the establishment of a new movement that blossomed in far-off California at the beginning of the 20th century called Pentecostalism.   Pentecostalism in the Carolinas has two parts - one is in the East, which was more Holiness/Wesleyan in background, and the other was in the West, from where the Church of God tradition evolved.  It is the eastern Holiness/Wesleyan aspect of Carolina Pentecostalism that impacts the events covered in this study, and without spending a lot of detail on it, I want to visit the highlights.
 
The Holiness movement was very influential in the Carolinas among Methodists in the mid-1800's due to the frontier-like revivalistic sympathies many people had.  The Free Will Baptists, also numerous in the same area, shared the Arminian sentiments of their Methodist neighbors, and likewise became influenced by Holiness spirituality.   The Azuza Street movement in 1906 that spawned Pentecostalism had as its hallmark an evangelical emphasis that drew people from all over, and one of the people who attended the meetings in Los Angeles was a young Methodist minister from South Carolina by the name of Gaston Barnabus Cashwell (1862-1916).  Cashwell was a protege of A.B. Crumpler, who was the de-facto founder of what would become the Pentecostal Holiness Church, and he influenced Cashwell to join his group sometime around 1903.  In 1906, when reports of the Azuza Street meetings reached the Carolinas, Cashwell had a desire to go and experience this for himself, and this happened in 1906.  Upon his return, Cashwell used his evangelistic gift to preach Pentecost at a series of meetings in Dunn, NC, and as a result the Pentecostal Holiness Church, Fire-Baptized Holiness Church (two early Holiness Wesleyan groups) and the Cape Fear Conference of the Original Free Will Baptists (later evolving into the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church) entered the Pentecostal movement officially (H.Vinson Synan, "Cashwell, Gaston Barnabas," in Burgess and Van Der Maas, The New International Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements {Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2002}p. 457).  And, from there, we see Pentecostal Free Will Baptists emerging in the Carolinas.
 
Gaston Barnabas Cashwell (1862-1916), apostle of Pentecost to the Carolinas
 
With that, we now have a sufficient background from which we can start dealing with specific groups in our study.
 
Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Groups in the Carolinas
 
We will now be exploring the smaller groups that chose not to affiliate with the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church upon its formal incorporation in 1959.   There are primarily four groups we wish to examine - the General Conference of the Evangelical Baptist Church, the Free Will Baptist Conference of Pentecostal Faith, the Trent River Freewill Holiness Association, and a group of independent congregations called "Free Will Baptist Holiness Churches."  
 
1.  The General Conference of the Evangelical Baptist Church, Inc.
 
Although having definite Free Will Baptist roots, this body seems to have developed somewhat independently of its sister churches, although it did embrace Pentecostalism at around the same time.  The Evangelical Baptist Church is largely the endeavor of a Free Will Baptist minister who embraced Pentecostalism by the name of William Howard Carter.  Carter, who began preaching at the age of 13, organized the Church of the Full Gospel in 1935, which later became known by its present name.  A man who by all accounts possessed great intellect and organizational ability, Dr. Carter was the founder of a college as well as greatly influential in civic affairs.  The center of the new church was around its headquarters in Goldsboro, NC, and for many years it maintained a small but vibrant presence.  In the late 1990's however, it almost ceased to exist until a new group of ministers revived it and relocated its headquarters to Tucson, AZ, where it also operates Arizona Bible College and Seminary.  Very little information is currently available on this group, although it still exists but seems to be still getting its bearings (Discipline of the the General Conference of the Evangelical Baptist Church {Tuscon, AZ: Executive Office, GCEBC, 2009} p. 9-10).
 
Dr. William Howard Carter, founder of the General Conference of the Evangelical Baptist Church in 1935.
 
Arizona Bible College and Seminary, Tucson, AZ.
 
2.  Free Will Baptist Conference of Pentecostal Faith
 
When the Cape Fear Conference of Original Free Will Baptists in North Carolina embraced the Pentecostal message in 1912, they were in fellowship with a conference in South Carolina that had similar convictions.  Its origins were in 1913, when a group of Free Will Baptists at a brush arbor meeting accepted the Pentecostal message after hearing the preaching of an evangelist named J.C. Pope who was with the Cape Fear conference after it had become Pentecostal.  This occurred near the town of Turbeville, SC, and the result was the formation of the Olive Grove Church which grew from a house meeting conducted by Pope and a Rev. Mills at the home of a Mr. A. M. Dennis.  the South Carolina conference was chartered in 1926, and it remained in fellowship with the North Carolina conferences until 1959, when it chose not to participate in the formation of the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church.  So, in 1961 the South Carolina Conference became the Free Will Baptist Conference of Pentecostal Faith.
 
In doctrine and practice, the FWBCPF is much more conservative and consistent with its Holiness roots than the PFWB is, as the latter is more these days like the Assemblies of God and has shed much of its more conservative Holiness traits.  the FWBCPF is still headquartered in South Carolina, and has under its fellowship roughly 20-some churches, all in South Carolina.  Although small, it still appears to be a vibrant group.  They do have a website at www.fwbpfc.com, but you may find it difficult to link to the information on the page as it hasn't been updated in a while.
 
headquarters of the Free Will Baptist Conference of Pentecostal Faith, Turbeville, SC.
 
3.  The Trent River Freewill Holiness Association
 
This third group is more unique still as its origins are different and although many of its tenets and constituency have Free Will Baptist roots, it doesn't identify specifically with the Free Will Baptists, although it does have good fellowship with the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church and similar groups.   It took a lot of years and a lot of effort to get information on this group, but thankfully they do have a web presence now, which aids in research tremendously!
 
The origins of the Trent River Association go back to 1946 and the evangelistic efforts of a bi-vocational revival minister by the name of Ruben Jones.   Jones was a tent-revival evangelist in the tradition of Oral Roberts, H. Richard Hall, and others who were his contemporaries at the time, and although I can't substantiate it concretely, it is likely that he had Free Will Baptist ties.  Jones' ministry was centered around the small community of Clinton, NC, and his efforts birthed a number of churches in the area that, beginning in 1946 until former charter in 1949, would become the Freewill Holiness Association.  The Association website also reports that Jones' ministry was noted for a number of signs and wonders, including miraculous healings, and he had a radio ministry in the area as well.  
 
Rev. Ruben Jones (d. 1996), revival evangelist and founder of the Trent River Freewill Holiness Association

Currently, the Trent River Association is headquartered in the town of Herring, NC, where it has had its offices since 1970.  It still has a campground near Clinton, and at present by my count it has 33 churches throughout North Carolina (mostly in the Eastern part of the state) in fellowship with it.  The current overseer is Ruben Jones' granddaughter, Dr. Teresa Ammons.  In practice, although the Association has the name "Holiness," it doesn't adhere to strict Holiness codes nor require them from its members, as many of its churches are essentially mainstream conservative Pentecostal congregations.  However, it still has a fascinating history, and most of the details of that can be found at their Association webpage - http://www.freewillholinessassociation.org/ - from which a lot of the material was gleaned for this article.  

Dr. Teresa Ammons, current General Overseer of the Trent River Association
 
Current headquarters of the Trent River Freewill Holiness Association, Herring, NC.
 
It is also a sidenote to mention that during the course of my research, there is another group of Freewill Holiness Churches in North Carolina called the Bible Freewill Holiness Conference.  They are listed as being headquartered near Red Springs, NC, but no information seems to be available on them at present.  However, perhaps further research will uncover more about that conference to share at a later date.
 
4.  Unaffilliated Free Will Baptist Holiness Churches
 
In the course of my research on these bodies, I have come across a significant number of congregations in the Carolinas containing the name "Free Will Baptist Holiness Church," and this sparked some interest.  At present, there are at least 20 such churches I have come across, and there seems to be different origins for each.  One group, headquartered around Anderson, SC, I was able to make contact with after discovering them on a Lexis/Nexis search a couple of years back.  This group consists of a single congregation under the name "Free Will Baptist Holiness Church," and it was incorporated on November 17,1926.  I was able to talk with the current elder, Rev. Vaudry Tucker Jr., and what he shared with me was that this congregation was founded by his father Vaudry Sr. as a Free Will Baptist Church with Pentecostal doctrine.  A stipulation was made in Vaudry Sr's will to keep the name, and today the church still exists.  It does not appear to have any connection with the Cashwell Dunn revivals in 1907 that birthed the Pentecostal Free Will Baptists and related groups however.
 
A similar group, incorporated in 1960 under the same name, also exists in Kinston, NC.  This group appears to have been organized by a minister named William Hamm, but other than that there is little information on them.  
 
A third group of churches bearing this name seems to be clustered around the cities of Gastonia and Charlotte, and they are apparently African-American congregations judging by the use of "Saint" in their church names.  This would actually be feasible, as there have been African-American Free Will Baptists for about 200 years (they have a denomination, the United American Free Will Baptist Association, headquartered in Kinston, NC), and many of those no doubt were impacted as well by the Dunn revivals of Cashwell, as he often held interracial meetings.  Therefore, it is almost certain that Pentecostal Free Will Baptist congregations among African-Americans existed, although for the time they would have been segregated, and my theory is that this is where these churches come in.  Although a lot of these congregations are listed on various internet databases, the problem is that they are almost impossible to contact to obtain further information.  Hopefully, with further research in the future I can have better success.  
 
The Apostle Freewill Baptist Holiness Church in Columbia, SC
 
Faith Chapel Freewill Baptist Holiness Church, Gastonia, NC
 
Freewill Baptist Holiness Chapel, Jonesville, NC
 

Mt. Calvary Freewill Baptist Holiness Church
 
New Mills Chapel Freewill Baptist Holiness Church, Gastonia, NC
 
Shiloh Freewill Baptist Holiness Church, Georgetown, SC
 
True Light Freewill Baptist Holiness Church, Easley, SC
 
Christian Baptist Churches of God in Ohio
 
The Carolina groups so far have all been identifiably Pentecostal, but in Ohio something else took place that produced a non-Pentecostal Holiness Free Will Baptist body which attracted my interest several years back.   The Ohio Valley Association of Christian Baptist Churches of God came into being sometime around the year 1931.  As mentioned, in southeastern Ohio, Free Will Baptists as well as Wesleyan/Holiness groups found fertile ground, and especially around the Scioto County area.  The Christian Baptists, however, were of mixed heritage due to the fact they resulted from a merger of elements of both Regular and Free Will Baptists.  The Free Will Baptist part of the story has already been discussed, so now I want to spend a little bit talking about the other parent group of this body, the Enterprise Association of Regular Baptists.
 
The Enterprise Association is an outgrowth of something unique to Appalachia, a non-missionary Calvinistic movement called Old-Time Baptists.  These Old-Time Baptists, as Howard Dorgan explains in his book Giving Glory to God in Appalachia (Knoxville:  University of Tennessee Press, 1987) are largely a result of a dispute over missionary activities among Baptists back in the 1820's, and the Regulars (as well as their more conservative brethren in KY, the Old Regulars) are a product of that along with the Primitive Baptists.   However, the Regulars were never as strict as the Primitives and Old Regulars, and the Enterprise Association in particular conducted much "correspondence" (meaning inter-fellowship cooperation, sharing pulpits, etc.) with the local Free Will Baptists.  It dates back to 1894 when it was organized in Kentucky, and today it has 56 churches in affilliation.  Over the years, it has also maintained fairly good relations with the Scioto Yearly Meeting of Free Will Baptists, which has a number of congregations in its same territory (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterprise_Association_of_Regular_Baptists, accessed 8/26/2013).  
In time, members of both groups began to desire a more formal union amongst themselves, and thus their efforts produced a new denomination.
 
The Marion Enterprise Regular Baptist Church, a constituent member of the Enterprise Association
 
In 1931, at the North Moreland Church in Portsmouth, OH, a group of ministers from both the Scioto Yearly and Enterprise Regular Associations met, and it was at this meeting that the Ohio Valley Association of Christian Baptist Churches was formed.  As of today, there are approximately 35 congregations associated with the Ohio Valley Association, which maintains its headquarters in the town of Wheelersburg, OH, where it also maintains a campground where it conducts an annual campmeeting.   The Ohio Association maintains excellent relationships still with its parent bodies(Calvin Ray Evans, a noted Free Will Baptist evangelist, is a popular speaker at their campmeetings, and a Christian Baptist minister, Rev. Brian Baer, serves on Evans' Boar of Directors), as well as with other conservative Evangelical Christians.  It is still a fairly conservative denomination, and has been influenced greatly by the Keswick movement (it denies, however, being in any way Wesleyan), which is why on many occasions it is classified as a Holiness group although this has been a subject of debate.   There is also a portion of its membership which embraces Pentecostal/charismatic convictions, and the Christian Baptists are noted for having emotional, warm services in which the raising of hands and the use of shaped-note gospel singing is utilized.  And, they do believe in divine healing, as they lay hands on the sick.  

The North Moreland Christian Baptist Church in Portsmouth, OH, where the Ohio Association was organized in 1931.
 
The headquarters of the Ohio Valley Association of Christian Baptist Churches, Wheelersburg, OH.
 
 
In summary, it is safe to say that Free Will Baptists have a heritage of receptivity to spiritual renewal, as all these groups forementioned can testify.  No doubt that fervent prayer and strong devotion to the faith has kept all these churches alive for decades, and they will have secure futures provided they stay faithful to their heritage.
 
Conclusion
 
This little history lesson introduced many of you to some fellowships and denominations that you may not have even imagined to have existed, but here they are!  One of the reasons I have always loved church history is the rich testimonies groups like this produce, and there is an exciting aspect to researching them.  Many of them, however, are woefully unaware of that themselves, and until recently some have ignored the importance of their own history altogether.   That fact has made my task a bit more daunting, but not impossible.  As I continue to share with you some other groups in later sections of this study, hopefully I will instill an appreciation of those little churches that no one thinks about - the most insignificant looking things can contain the richest bounty.  God bless you until next time.
 
____________________________________________________________________________________
 
I wish to acknowledge several people who aided in this endeavor, as without their efforts I could not have gotten much of this information.  First, many thanks to Mr. Gary Barefoot, who is an archivist at Mount Olive College, for providing a lot of valuable information on early North Carolina Free Will Baptist history.  I also want to express appreciation to the late Goldie Taylor, a retired missionary with the Christian Baptists who was my initial contact with them.   I also want to thank Rev. Wayne Parker for his assistance with providing information on the Trent River Freewill Holiness Association.  Finally, for all the groups, including the Pentecostal Free Will Baptist Church, for sending me copies of their directories, histories, disciplines, etc.   God bless each and all of them for their invaluable assistance with this project.  
 

  
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 

  
  
 
  
  

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

All Things Work Together, But Maybe We Don't See the Big Picture!

Note - This was the text for a sermon I composed for a recent graduate-level Homiletics class.  There are some things here that I was unable to address due to time factors and other restrictions in the class, but we will do so here where I have the liberty to do so.  Hope this message will edify the listener.

The pericope in Scripture we are focusing on for this lesson today is taken from Romans 8:26-39, and it is chosen because it is the Epistle lesson for the 11th Sunday in Trinity, upon which date this sermon approximates.  The Trinity season focuses on Christ's teachings, challenging us to make practical applications of them in our own lives.  However, in doing so, we have to first be consecrated as vessels of the love of God to others.

In this passage, there are three important but interrelated aspects communicated to challenge us, and they are intercession, predestination, and inseparability. 

Beginning with verses 26-27, let us first talk a little about intercession.  First, intercession is done according to God's will for us.  Second, the Holy Spirit intercedes through us.  In the latter case, ultimately it is not us doing the interceding, but rather the voice of God Himself, for as believers His Holy Spirit does dwell within us.   The late evangelist Kathryn Kuhlman illustrated this idea well in one of her classic quotes - she often said "God doesn't want gold or silver vessels, but rather yielded vessels!"  She stated a valid observation, because it is indeed God who dwells within us that enables us to do what he called us to do.  Problem is, do we listen??  That could be the subject of a whole other message!

Secondly, in some cases this intercession is manifested by "groanings which cannot be uttered," according to verse 27.  Now, among many of our Pentecostal and Charismatic friends, this reference is often used as Scriptural support for the gift of speaking in unknown tongues, and I would concede that there is some validity to that.  However, the old-time Pentecostal folks understood this on a different level as well.  Some among them had what is known as a "gift of travail," and what that meant was that such a person with this gift would receive what was called a "burden" to intercede on behalf of someone else, usually for salvation, healing, or some important need of that person.  In interceding for this need, the person who did so would often display an almost agonizing demonstration of prayer, fasting, and it could last for days at a time - the person would indeed "groan inutterable groanings" that many equated with the agony of the birthing process a woman has.  This is also comparable to Isaiah 26, where similar imagery occurs.   Although it looked strange, God used it, and oftentimes the end result of such action would be a miraculous breakthrough of some sort.  Such was the old-time Pentecost of the past - what happened today??  In the past several decades, many people who once took this stuff seriously have passed on, and the new generation oftentimes doesn't display the commitment that these old-timers had.  And, with the distractions of the modern world, more focus is directed by many churches and their leaders on how to tickle ears, entertain, and in general Christianity has been "dumbed-down" by a postmodern generation that doesn't know the true faith as their forebears once did.  One of our traditional Anglican lay writers, Barton Gingerich, wrote an article recently that addressed this problem, and what he said was (based on research done by Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquist Denton) basically the postmodern generation is in a faith crisis of "kind," and what he means by this is simple - many of these young people were not properly discipled in true Christianity in the first place, but rather a philosophy called Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (MTD), which has the following core tenets:

1.  A single god exists who created and ordered the cosmos.
2.  Said "god" wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other - ie: "Thou shalt not be a jerk."
3.  God does not need to be particularly involved in one's life unless a problem needs to be solved.
4.  Good people go to heaven when they die.
(Barton Gingerich, "The Rise of the 'Nones'," in The Anglican Way {vol. 26, no. 2} 2013. p. 15)

To me, this sounds like nothing more than good old politically-correct universalist nonsense, not to mention a secularization of Christianity.  Fr. Alexander Schemann, the preeminent Orthodox theologian and late chancellor of St. Vladimir Seminary in New York, once said that secularism is a religion in and of itself, and its primary tenet is that man has the responsibility to make life as interesting, happy, and meaningful as possible, but he also notes that as much as secularism is a faith of "helps," it takes more than that to be a Christian (Alexander Schemann, For The Life of the World {Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir Seminary Press, 2004} pp 98-99).  That Christianity is slowly secularizing is of no great mystery - the individualistic mentality of Protestant Evangelicalism almost guarantees it will happen!  Archbishop Haverland also notes this, as he observes that the authority of personal religious experience divorced from the clear historic teachings of the Church will in time lead to secularization (Mark Haverland, Anglican Catholic Faith and Practice {Athens, GA: Anglican Parishes Association, 2011} p. 63).  And, that is why, in recent years, we have seen postmodernism infect much of American Christianity.  At the Pentecostal college I went to as a matter of fact, I have noted an alarming difference between when I was there as an undergraduate student over 20 years ago and what it is today - in its past, this college had a vibrant spiritual legacy, and revivals were more frequent back then because faculty at that time were godly men who had a vision for their students.  However, today it is all about activism, moralism, and money - the focus of the campus today is one of numbers and what entertains people, and the campus revivals of the past have been replaced with "leadership forums" and other nonsense trying to make the church look like the corporate world.  And, the spiritual atmosphere reflects this - it is dead, lifeless, and there is no continuity with the legacy it once had.  MTD, rather than Biblical Christianity, has overtaken both the campus and the impressionable young students.  Scary stuff - and, it is the reason why you don't see a lot of people who possess the gift of intercession; God forbid we interrupt our precious schedules so God can talk to us, because we only need to talk to him when we are in trouble!  This is a tragic and terrible.

The Christian East understood the intercessory ministry as well, in particular such great Church Fathers as St. Symeon the New Theologian, who taught extensively on a "gift of tears" that although not exclusively tied to intercessory prayer was intimately connected to it.  Intercession, bottom line, is a lost art, and it is tragic that it is so ignored in favor of a moralistic deism that appeals to the flesh while imperiling the eternity of the soul in hell.

Moving on from intercession, the Apostle inserts a peripheral thought in verse 28 which  affirms that God is ultimately in control, and that all things work together for His good for those who love him and are called to his purpose.  To tie it into the earlier verses, it means that real intercession is not an effort in vain, but will produce results.  In regard to this also, this "working together" also includes adversity, and my spiritual mentor, Fr. Eusebius Stephanou, summarizes that beautifully when he says "Man's disappointments are God's appointments."  Fr. Eusebius often uses the Biblical story of Joseph to illustrate what he means - essentially, the evil and adversity inflicted upon Joseph was used to orchestrate God's eventual favor, and the poor Hebrew kid sold into slavery becomes the second-most powerful man in a foreign land!  Remember though that one's faithfulness is still a determining factor in that equation, and we must remain faithful and obedient to the Lord in order for him to direct us where he wills us to go.  That being said, it also recalls a statement I heard another well-known minister say one time - "One's present position doesn't determine one's future potential."  What that is saying to us is that we need to look at the bigger picture and not let the adversity we face at times distract us from remembering God is ultimately in control of all things.

We now want to address predestination.  This word is often misunderstood, and some of our Calvinist/Reformed friends often misappropriate it to the point it can become a bad word.  Reformed Calvinists are fellow Christians, and they have produced many fine ministers and scholars (D. James Kennedy and Francis Schaeffer come to mind here).  However, the more extreme followers of this school of thought tend to go one of two extreme directions.  Some espouse what is called supralapsarianism, which is also known as the "Radical Two-Seed Doctrine." Those who espouse this view take predestination to mean that God has given some - called "the elect" - his holy seed, and they are predestined to salvation.  Others have "Satan's seed," and the more extreme proponents of this view will go as far as to state that Eve had sex with Satan, birthed Cain, and that "seed" has descendants today who are doomed to damnation with no hope of redemption - one proponent of this view was early Pentecostal evangelist William Branham.  This of course contradicts the true Word of God, which says Jesus died for all, and that anyone who accepts His atonement for our sins on the Cross will be saved.   The other extreme is rooted in the same mentality, and has recently gained some popularity, and that would be universalism.  A Reformed/Calvinistic universalism affirms that Christ died for all, and as a result, all have been predestined to salvation.  The most recent incarnation of this heresy is Rob "No Hell" Bell's controversial book Love Wins.  Both of these extremes are wrong, and neither represent what Scripture clearly teaches.  But to address that, one needs to differentiate between predestination and foreknowledge.  Predestination means a course has been set by God Himself for one's life pilgrimage, in that he knew us before we existed.  Foreknowledge, on the other hand, denotes a variability based on the free will God gave us.  God gives us the decision to make, but based on the choice he knows the outcome of it.  I like what early Church writer Theodoret of Cyr said in regard to the difference, as he correctly pointed out that God's foreknowledge does not predestine someone to salvation or baptism.  And, that leads us into the final idea of this passage, which is inseparability.

Inseparability is the word I chose to describe what is being communicated in the final verses of this passage, and essentially what it means is that once we have accepted Christ and know God's love, no external force can separate us from that!  Note external force, and look at the rhetorical interrogatory the Apostle engages, beginning in verse 35, when he asks if several external stimuli - tribulation, distress, persecution, famine, nakedness - can separate us from the love of Christ.  In verses 38-39, he answers the question by affirming that these and some additional externals - death, life, angels, principalities, powers, things present, things to come, height, depth, no other creature - can separate us from the love of God, manifested fully in Jesus Christ.  Note however what is not mentioned - temptation, the will, and our own flesh!  Those things are not external, but are part of us - God does not will that any should perish eternally in their sin, and it is not God who ultimately sends us to hell if we reject His salvation.  Rather, we do it ourselves.  Scripture affirms that backsliding is indeed a possibility, and eschatologically it is guaranteed to happen on a large scale as an apostasy is foretold many times in Scripture among those professing Christ.  And, it is not external stimuli that cause the apostasy, but rather the weakness of the human flesh!  A misunderstanding of this truth has led over the years to a couple of common errors.  One one hand, you have some radical Calvinists, who believing they are predestined to be saved anyway engage in a mindset known as antinomianism.  Antinomianism asserts that due to the fact that one's salvation is secure no matter what, such a person can engage in sinful behavior with no consequence.  This is a clear heresy, and also does not represent historic soteriology - the Church affirms that at the administration of baptism, all original sin is eradicated and the person becomes a new life in Christ.  However, we still have a sin nature, and must have a living faith in order to keep it in check - when we sin, in other words, the Holy Spirit should be present in our lives to convict us of that sin so that we can repent of it and remain in a state of grace.  God is faithful and just to forgive all who sincerely and humbly repent of sin, but we must be responsive enough in our Christianity to do so.  Therefore, antinomianism is not an option.   A second error was advanced on the other extreme by late Orthodox theologian Seraphim Rose called the "Tollhouse Theory," and what that entails is that when a believer dies, their souls can still be snatched and drug into hell by demonic "watchers" as the soul ascends to heaven.  This too is a clear heresy, and a misunderstanding and misappropriation of the spiritual conflict we experience in this life.  Be assured, if you die with a vibrant faith in Jesus Christ as your Savior, and His blood has atoned for your sins, your eternal reward is pretty much guaranteed, and those "tollhouse watchers" (also external forces - principalities) cannot steal that away because they have no authority to do so. 
That being said, it is important to know that we need to know what we believe - I hear even some pastors saying they are still "developing their theology," and if that is the case, they are in BIG trouble! - because deception is out there, and the enemy will use it to try to derail us.  And, that is why it is tragic that today much of postmodern Christianity doesn't have a clue when it comes to doctrine, apologetics, or history - the generation suffers as a result.  That tragedy must be averted before more people are lost for eternity.

In closing, let's tie it all together.  First, God has things under control, and if you are his, you are his vessel and nothing external can touch you.  However, you must remain faithful, or you will fall, simple as that.  As long as we allow God the primacy in our lives, He will take care of and look out for us.  Thankfully, his love and salvation are not contingent on external stimuli either, and that is the beauty of our own testimonies as Christians.  May we continue to walk faithfully in that path he has pre-ordained for us. 

Friday, July 12, 2013

Biblical Principles In the Workplace - A Study on Ephesians 6:5-9

This article is actually a chapter of a book I am finishing up which consists of a series of Bible studies on the Book of Ephesians.  The original context of the passage under discussion was dealing with slaves and masters, but in this case I have appropriated it to the modern workplace.  I hope this will help you and encourage you in your daily lives.


 Now that we have dealt with the family relationship, the focus of the study now will be on an area that is significant to many of us because it takes up a significant portion of our daily lives - our jobs. 
Work is vital to live.  Everything this day and age costs something, and in order to acquire the currency that the cost entails, we have to invest our own resources to generate that income.  That is the fundamental principle as to why we are able to bring home our paychecks every week; the money represented by that rectangular piece of paper represents what we have invested out abilities and strengths into in order to assure the acquisition of basic provisions for our survival.  Work of course is not a pleasant subject - to be honest, it's the last thing I personally want to think about after doing it all day long, especially if it is a job in which you feel doesn't really showcase your talents and abilities God gave you, and at times it doesn't pay what it should either.  My own work history, honestly, has not been ideal - in order to support my family and pay my bills, I've had to take some rather - pardon me for saying it - crappy jobs that either paid inadequately or the work environment was such that at times I could not stomach it.  Frankly, there have been times I have actually dreaded the day dawning, especially at times when we were without our own transportation and had to rely on the city bus.  Many who have been in that situation can understand what it is to arise at 5:30 AM just to be at work by 9:00 AM.  With the sour national economy in recent years, many of us have also found ourselves on occasion being herded by groups into conference rooms, where after everyone is seated we are all handed these yellow envelopes and told we are being let go because of a fiscal downturn.  In working many years in the secular field as a mortgage professional, I have been there a few times on both counts.   Back in November 2003, for example, I worked for one of the largest banks in the country when the real estate market took one of the worst downturns it had experienced in years.  On that particular autumn day, about 100 of us were called by the two VP's of Operations into a conference room, handed those big yellow envelopes - which to be fair did contain very generous severance packages for the time, which was a blessing - and then told the company could not afford to keep us anymore, and thus we were being let go.  Corporate America, a behemoth entity that operates on what could be called a Darwinist "survival of the fittest" form of economics (also called greed) has depersonalized many workplaces in the past 50 or so years to the degree that both the average employees and management often merely "go through the motions" on a daily basis just to do what is minimally necessary to keep their jobs.  In 1999. a movie producer/writer by the name of Mike Judge created a cult classic film called Office Space which vividly portrayed that conundrum, and Judge made a fortune off that film due to the fact it touched a nerve with people - many of us who have seen it multiple times saw ourselves in it, and unlike much of the Hollywood fluff you see today, Office Space was a brutally realistic movie.  If Judge were a Christian (and I pray maybe he does find Christ one day) he would actually be a prime candidate for a gift of prophecy to be honest.  The main accomplishment of this cult-classic movie was that it gave a voice to the frustrations many of us - myself included - feel at times; it's as if we are wasting our lives away without really achieving much of significance.  Add to that then our consumer-driven society - 90% of America is in debt to some degree, this forcing a lot of talented people who could do greater things into a corporate prison, languishing behind the dull, grey, carpeted walls of tight cubicles.  Thing is though, for what??  To get that big screen TV that they probably charged to the yazoo on a credit card which has a credit limit significantly higher than the annual salary the corporation gives them?  Honestly, much of this is a complicated bi-product of the so-called "Industrial Revolution" which occurred in the early 19th century, which in turn led to the rise of an elite group that many writers called the "Robber Barons" (Rockefeller, J.P. Morgan, Cornelius Vanderbilt, Andrew Carnegie, and others like them).  The worldview of this new system was incompatible with the Judeo-Christian ethos, and instead had more in common with social Darwinism (many of these "Barons" were, interestingly, committed evolutionists), and that mentality set in motion a great upheaval to the order of things as they had been for centuries.  However, the word of God, in particular this passage we will be discussing in Ephesians, does actually address this very issue.  In the context of the day - St. Paul wrote this at the height of the classical Roman Imperial period - the verses in this pericope were addressed primarily to masters and their servants, but they are by all means applicable to 21st-century America as well.   All we need to do is replace the words "slave" and "master" with "employee" and "employer," and there you go!  Therefore, focusing on Ephesians 6:5-9, we are going to deal with this important issue, due to its connotations for today's society.

Although some religious authorities have tried to reduce the Bible to merely a "religious book," (notably Melkite Archbishop Cyril Bustros, liberal Roman Catholic writer and Paulist priest Robert Rivers in his book From Maintenance to Mission, and Emerging Church leader Brian McLaren, as well as liberal Protestant theologians such as Stanley Hauerwas and Jurgen Moltmann) with no relevance to any other discipline, the fact of the matter is the Bible is a book that imparts wisdom to all areas of life - it addresses science, history, politics, medicine, and yes, even economics!  Rev. John Broome, the Assemblies of God minister who officiated Barb's and my wedding some 21 years ago as of this writing, once said in one of his sermons that for the Christian, every issue we face in life is a theological issue, and he was absolutely correct!  Being the Bible is God's revelation to us, it addresses all of these issues too in some way - the focus of the Bible is the legacy of the salvation and redemption of mankind, and part of that has to do with the complexies of human nature as well as God's created order of things in this world.  The Bible is the most perfect instruction book which deals with keeping God at the center of all areas of our lives, whether it be family, work, the worshipping community, etc.   And, while some would say that the Bible is not primarily a history book, or an economics text, etc. - and they are correct - what it does address in relation to those issues is 100% reliable, and it was inspired by God himself.  Therefore, if people would really open themselves up to the possibilities, the Bible could really govern a nation (not the book itself obviously, but the truth within it as applied and appropriated by leadership that believes and trusts in those truths).  The fundamental problem, however, is that sinful man rebels against God's ways, although God's ways are meant to be for our own benefit.  And, like all other areas of life, Biblical principles and truths can be applied in our workplaces as well.

The passage under discussion addresses both Christian employees and Christian employers, an in doing so it does something significant.  Essentially, here are the two fundamental lessons it teaches us:

1.  Employees need to respect and obey their employers, as God ordained the employer to be where he is and blessed the employee with the job to earn income to provide for his or her family's needs.

2.  Employers - meaning here specifically Christian employers - need to realize that their employees who may also be Christians are also their brethren, and should be treated with the dignity and respect due them.  The true leader is a servant to those he or she leads.

That being said, the godly way a Christian business should be run is this - the dignity of each man or woman being created in God's image plays a vital part in how both the employer and employee treat one another.  A solid Christ-centered atmosphere in the workplace does have results - the employees will exhibit a deep loyalty to their employer who treats them with said dignity, and the end result of that is the quality of the work or service will be superior.  There are even some non-Christian employers who understand this principle without even knowing where they got the understanding from in many cases.   A prime example of this was a title company I used to work for some years back, a small company owned and operated by a brilliant real estate attorney.  To be honest, it was one of the best gigs I have personally had the privelege of working, and it was due to the attorney's work ethic - he once said a happy employee is a productive employee.  Therefore, this attorney (who unfortunately passed away a few years back from terminal cancer) treated his employees (even temporary and contract people!) like royalty - for a period of time, as an example, the company even bought everyone in the office lunch everyday, and they paid salaries that were generous and far superior to the average salary of the geographic area.  The end result was that this small office developed a close-knit support grid among the employees, and many of us are still good friends today as we worked well with each other.  And, whereas in many companies people scatter when lunchtime rolls around, we would joyfully work through our lunch breaks without even an issue, and overtime when necessary was something we had no problem with either.  In short, due to the generous attitude and respect of this employer for his employees, the goals of the employer became the goals of the employees, and a strong cohesion resulted that is a rare find in many offices today.  As an extra measure, the office managers were always there for the staff too, and without hesitation help was extended to an employee who was going through a rough time at home or something.  Although many of the people I worked with in this title office were by no means what you'd call committed Christians (a couple were, but not many) they still stand out as a stellar example of the Scriptural principles we will be discussing, which is why I spent some detail sharing this.

The Apostle Paul, in verses 5-7, first addresses employees, and these are five primary things he stressed that should be hallmarks of a Christian worker:

1.  Obedience to the employer is a must, for he is paying for their services, and the employees owe him a quality service for the investment he is making.

2. It is important, as the Apostle writes, to be obedient "with fear and trembling."  Now, this in no way implies that we should be in fear of our employers, but we need to afford them a healthy respect that says "my job depends on how well I serve this company."  Remember, in this day and age, no one is indispensable in Corporate America, and no job is completely secure, even a corporate executives.  This would also fall under the Biblical principle of responsible stewardship.

3. Sincerity in our work is paramount.  We need to be able to sincerely do the best job we can, and be honest in our strengths and weaknesses.  A good employer respects that level of integrity.  Many professing Christians fall short of this, and we could even take a lesson from non-Christians at times - for one, the Jains, who are bound by a code of honesty in their religion and to be honest I would trust a Jain with my personal financial portfolio anyday! - although this does not give sanction for equating other religions with our faith - we serve the one true God, which is why even more we should exemplify that in our relations with society as a whole, in particular the workplace, where many of us do spend a significant portion of our time.

4.  We don't do things with "eye service" (meaning trying to "look good") or try to be manpleasers (in modern vernacular, rumpkissers).  An astutely observant supervisor can easily detect these false pretenses when an employee is trying to "kiss up," and it is not flattery, but actually insults the boss.  In that case, flattery will truly get you nowhere. (v.6)

5. Perfection is not so much the goal, nor should it be realistically expected, but especially as Christians in the workplace we do our best.  That is pleasing to both God and the boss, and will in time have its own rewards. (v. 8)

6.  Our jobs are a ministry - a nonbelieving employer can be reached by the witness of a diligent employee who knows the Lord.  The result then is that good service brings God's favor. (vv. 7-8)
Now, I need to stress here that even in the most adverse conditions - you may be underpaid, overworked, and just in a nasty job - a Christian can do this.  There are many times I personally have had to "suck it up" and do the job I was paid to do despite how much I personally detested my boss or workplace, or how inadequately I was paid.  If in that position, let me say to you there's no harm in looking for something better if it escalates into a serious issue, but as you do so don't burn your proverbial bridges - any hostile behavior due to frustration could come back to haunt you later, and I too have made that mistake, so know what I am saying.  The bottom line to all this, however, is about living up to personal responsibilities - remember, we all have bills to pay and many of us do have our families to consider.

Now that we've talked about employees and their expectations, let us now turn to employers.  In the past 100 years or so, the business world has changed drastically.  In the late 1800's and early 1900's, most businesses were largely of what is called the "mom-and-pop" variety, which meant they were usually small, family-owned and operated, with maybe a few trusted hired community people to help out.  Many unrelated employees worked for these businesses for years, in many cases becoming close friends to the family who owned the business.  The result of that was quality goods and services, as quality was prioritized over quantity of production.  These family-run businesses often depended on the revenue of the businesses for their livelihoods, and the business ethic which made such enterprises click was largely foundated on Judeo-Christian principles, which didn't allow for the greed and obsession with wealth many large corporations today are characterized by.  However, with the "Industrial Revolution" of the late 1700's, and the rise of a greedy elite class of "Robber Barons" in the ensuing years, a radical change transpired.  Base human greed and selfishness came into the picture, and with the popularity of a new mindset which had its genesis in an 1879 book by naturalist Charles Darwin entitled Origin of the Species, the attitude of self-gratification became a new religion, and as a result the Judeo-Christian ethic of the small local businesses became passe.  Rather, the new goal became the acquisition of wealth at any cost rather than the provision of needed services.  Quantity, therefore, began to usurp quality, and it only took less than a century for this new selfishness to permeate the American business establishment.  Now, many years later, the days of the "mom-and-pop" establishment are practically over (those businesses, many now called "cottage industries," are still out there, but Corporate America, with bankrolled politicians in its back pocket, is slowly rubbing these out), and many good "mom-and-pops" have been swallowed up by larger, richer corporations who promised the public the mantric "more for less" (more supply at cheaper prices - also inferior quality as a side effect - to meet a greater demand).  However, in that process, we have lost something precious - the close community that existed betwen small business owners and their employees has been replaced by a corporate elite hidden away in the "ivory tower" seclusion of skyscraper penthouses, pontificating from their opulent thrones monotonous policies and procedures to a grossly underpaid working caste who go about their duties robotically on a daily basis, many losing valuable time with their families.  This has produced dire results on society as a whole - high divorce rates, substance abuse, an increase in suicides, etc.  (not to mention mountains of hopelessly-entangling consumer debt).  Average workers are viewed often by the management as numbers and statistics, and these corporations spend millions of dollars on "motivational seminars" and other nonsense to supposedly make workers more of a "team."  I have in our back storage room here at the house a box of books I have received from companies I have worked for talking about "right attitudes," "address to impress," and so forth, but is all that really necessary??  Now even churches are playing these games, and the tragic result of that is that the truth of the Gospel is either being diluted or outright suppressed in order to make room for the "effective programs."  This stuff personally sickens me, because as I have found out, they are mere fads that a company uses to brainwash its employees into submission, but often things like this backfire.  For instance, a few years ago, companies were big into all this ""life coaching" stuff, and the large bank I worked for at the time even had me take a course on that.  However, I learned something - the coaching class, rather than being a tool for increased production, became a weapon that wise employees like myself utilized to call management on the carpet and to accountability, and of course, management hated that and as a result such programs fell by the wayside, and thousands of dollars got flushed down the crapper.  Here's a thought - instead of investing in those fads, why doesn't the company start treating their employees like human beings instead of machines, and maybe - just maybe!! - if the employees felt like management respected them, production and quality of work could be improved and that money which would have been wasted on stupid seminars and such could be disseminated as raises and bonuses for the employees!  I am really not against these things like "life coaching" either, believe it or not - some of these things can be appropriated with Biblical principles, and they can be quite helpful.  However, corporations often use such things as a manipulation tool to bleed their workers dry.  Christian employers thankfully don't have to resort to that.  In Ephesians 6:9, God inspired the Apostle, St. Paul, to pen some very effective and basic principles that, if taken seriously, will revolutionize a workplace.  Here are some of those admonitions in this passage that provide Christian businesses with principles to follow:

1. Do Not Threaten!! Just as employees are dispensable, the employer is advised that the door swings both ways.  An employee always working under intimidating threats of losing their job, "being written up," etc., will be too cowed to do a good service. Threatening and aggression always makes things worse.

2. Don't Show Partiality!! A boss who gives into "kissing up" and flattery is not a genuine leader.  And, that type of favoritism creates a very hostile work environment.  That is a lesson that Corporate America really needs to get beaten into it.  In my experience of interviewing for jobs, I have picked up some things, and here they are:

a. A lot of employers do not actually read resumes, and as a result good people are often looked over for jobs they are more than capable of doing well.
b.  There seems to be an unwritten code as to who gets jobs these days, as I have found out the hard way.  Basically, there are three requirements with most (although there are exceptions) corporations that have absolutely nothing to do with one's skills or experience, and here they are:

  • i.    What you look like
  • ii.   Who you know
  • iii. How well you kiss up and flatter

3.  Respect Your Employees!!  A boss over a department in a large company, or a corporate executive for that matter, needs to realize that the people populating that vast monolithic, monotonous sea of cubicles outside their office door are people - many are highly intelligent, sufficiently skilled individuals who work hard, but also have limitations.  The boss often demands respect, but fails to understand that the law of reciprocity comes into play; a boss has to respect to receive respect!  A Christian manager or executive is held to even a higher standard than that, for his or her employees who are fellow Christians are their brothers and sisters in Christ, and that involves a whole other set of Biblical principles which come into play.

4. Lead By Being A Servant!!  The best leaders are those who serve the best interests of those they lead.  A boss is on the payroll of his or her company, bu that does not dismiss their responbilities to those whom they are charged with leading.  Often, the boss is an employee's only source of justice, and the boss does a tremendous service by voicing the workers' concerns to the management.  If more supervisors in certain industries would have thought like that in the first place, then labor unions would never have been necessary (Unions often do more harm than good anyway, so the world would do better without them).  Ultimately though, the best boss is a godly boss, for a boss who knows the Lord has the example of Christ to draw from.  E. Truett Cathy, the head of the Chik-Fil-A restaurant chain, is an excellent example of godly corporate leadership.  Also, my former boss, the late John Ritter of Royal Title and Escrow in Miami, FL, was as well although I am not totally sure of his religious commitments. 

To summarize, we have talked about various levels of relationship over the past few studies - the family, the Church, and here the workplace.  Ultimately, good relationships in all areas of our lives form a bulwark against the attacks of the enemy, and in essence those relationships are the fortresses of our spiritual battles.  They provide the reinforcement and support we need to overcome those attacks.  That being said, we will in the final chapter of these studies talk about the spiritual war we face every day of our lives, and as we do so, you will hopefully see how these relationships come into play as important standards against the onslaught of the enemy.

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

On the Great Schism, the Reformation, and Other Church Divisions

I have studied Church History (and history in general) for many years as a personal interest, and in doing so I have come across a number of things that have revolutionized commonly-held versions of "history" of all sorts that we are often told.  I wanted to just share a few observations today, because they are some things that have been on my mind and I needed to talk about. 

First, let me say that I was chrismated in the Maronite Rite of the Roman Catholic Church back on Easter of 2000, and that being the case, I want to say that I view the Roman Catholic tradition as a valid expression of Christianity, and Rome is an integral part of the Church.  I am no longer in the Roman Catholic Church, being part of the Continuing Anglo-Catholic movement instead, but I still value much that our Roman brethren have to offer.  They have also produced some tremendously gifted scholars, such as Scott Hahn, that I reference extensively for my own research. Rome is still Christian, is still part of the whole Church, and as such she deserves proper respect and appreciation for her contributions to the Christian tradition as a whole. I said that because what I am about to say in no way invalidates Rome's position as part of Christianity, but it shows that all of us are still human and are prone to error, and that is why I felt the conviction to address this.

Although the Roman Catholics are an integral part of the Church, and many of them are fine Christian people, Rome as a whole has made some mistakes over the centuries, namely in some of its more distinctive teachings which are not in concord with the teachings of the Church as a whole.  For one thing, there is Papal primacy and infallibility.   This was the issue that caused the Christian East and the Western Church to split back in AD 1054, and it was largely due unfortunately to a misunderstanding of the office of the Bishop of Rome.  The Church, as I have read and understood it, was founded to be governed by a collegiality of bishops, without any having primacy over the others.   Rome violated that early on when all of a sudden the "Primacy of Peter" issue, based on a faulty interpretation of Matthew 16:18, which was when Jesus said to Peter, "Thou art Peter (in Greek petra, a feminine noun denoting a large slab of rock, as opposed to the masculine word lithos, which is used to refer to anything from a pebble to a bolder) and upon this rock I will build My Church."  Jesus said that to Peter after the famous confession Peter proclaimed a couple of verses earlier that Jesus was the Son of God and the Messiah (v. 16).   Theodore of Mopsuestia, in one of his writings, notes that this petra was the same faith and confession Peter made that would be the foundation of the Church - Jesus is God the Son, and that also is concurrent with John 1:1 as well.   Peter's role in this was that he would be given a leadership in the Church as an Apostle, but one of many, and the confession he spoke (which was from God himself, if one looks in verse 17) would be the discerning key of true faith and belief (Manlio Simonetti, ed. Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture, Vol. 1b - Matthew 14-28 {Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2002}. pp. 45-46).  I see here a direct correlation between this verse and a parable of Jesus spoken in Matthew 7:24, which says that those who hear and believe (or do, as the Duahy-Rheims translates it) will be likened unto a man who built his house on a foundation of a solid rock.  It is not enough to accept Jesus, in other words, as merely a historical figure who existed, but rather belief in what He said and who He is constitutes building upon the petra, thus having a sound foundation of faith.   The basis of all Holy Tradition of the Church is in the personage of Jesus Christ, who is its Head, its Lord, and its Founder.  Peter was the first to acknowledge that with insight from the Holy Spirit, and thus his confession codifies the fundamental reason for Jesus coming to earth - as God in the flesh to save mankind.  Therefore, the rock it speaks of in Matthew 16:18 is not a person, and definitely is not the Papal office, but rather the ultimate wellspring from which the doctrine of the Church rests - the personage of Christ as God the Son and Savior of those who will believe in Him.  This by no means diminishes Peter's Apostolic authority though - he was instrumental in the founding and establishment of three of the major Churches of Christianity; Jerusalem, Antioch, and Rome.  Where our Roman Catholic brethren err though is by saying that this makes the "See of St. Peter" the ultimate head of the Church, which it does not.  The ultimate authority of the Church and her witness are in the belief that Jesus is God the Son, come into the world to save mankind from their sins.  That is how the rest of the Church has viewed this for centuries, and that fact is the true rock of foundation for our faith as Christians. 

Another area that has gotten Rome into some trouble is this idea of purgatory.  Purgatory is, in Roman Catholic dogma, an intermediate place for cleansing of the righteous dead before they enter the Kingdom.  However, in some Roman Catholic writings, purgatory looks an awful lot like hell, and its temporary state has been even taken to extremes by some mystics who have evolved a universalistic understanding of soteriology.  There is, interesting enough, some Scriptural support for this, as in Luke 16:19 there is the parable of Lazarus and the rich man, which described a place called "Abraham's Bosom" where Jesus eventually preached to the righteous dead and brought them into heaven.  Purgatory evolved out of this, but those who evolved a doctrine of purgatory from this idea failed to realize that Jesus did away with that once He died and was resurrected, therefore conquering death and the grave.  Any idea of purgatory ends with that, and the Roman Catholic version of this is not consistent with what the rest of the Church believes, although it has produced some bizarre variations among both Protestants and Orthodox.  On one extreme, for instance, you have late Orthodox theologian Fr. Seraphim Rose, who taught what is called the "Tollhouse Doctrine," which essentially says that even the righteous dead can be snatched as their souls ascend by demons at these specific places in the heavens called "tollhouses," and dragged into hell.   This is rightly called by Orthodox priest Fr. Michael Azkoul a form of neo-Gnosticism.   The best refutation of such heresy comes from the Church Fathers themselves, in this case the great St. John Chrysostom, who wrote in his Homily on Lazarus the following: "For if while the soul dwells in the body the devil cannot bring violence about it, clearly when it departs from the body, he likewise has no power over it." (Michael Azkoul, A Bad Penny: The Toll-Houses Again {Dewdney, BC: Synaxis Press, n.d} p. 1).  This would also refute purgatory as the Roman Catholics understand it as well.  The other extreme is this recent rise by "Emerging Church" proponents such as Rob Bell, in his controversial book Love Wins, which espouses a form of universalism that suggests hell itself is temporary and eventually everyone (including Satan and the demons) will be saved by Christ, due to the fact the overwhelming love of God will ultimately destroy hell.  However, Bell and his kind (including Carlton Pearson, the ex-Pentecostal minister who about 10 years ago began teaching something similar called the "Gospel of Inclusion") fail to realize that this contradicts orthodox views of hell, sin, and salvation by essentially taking away the need for a Savior, and ultimately erasing God-given free will.  For one thing, Bell forgets (or ignores) to realize that God is not the one that sends people to hell - fallen humanity has condemned itself there, and only belief in Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of our sins will save us - the Blood of Jesus is very important, but it must be accepted to be effective by us as individuals.  It is indeed offered to all, and Jesus loves all mankind and did die for all mankind, but mankind has to accept and believe what Jesus did on the Cross to find salvation.  Secondly, hell is eternal, and the Church has always taught that it was originally created for Satan and the fallen angels who will be doomed to spend eternity there once Jesus comes back, but humanity chose to believe Satan's lies and also by default inherited the curse of eternal damnation, which can only be broken by the shed Blood of Jesus for our sins.  The nullification of free will by Bell and others like him is due in large part to Calvinistic influence, but there is also a root of the same error that Roman Catholics often use to justify purgatory's existence.   Bottom line is, the Church as a whole has never taught purgatory's existence, and as a result the potential exists for heresy by those who do accept it. 

There are also some Marian doctrines that Rome introduced which do not reflect the consensual tradition of the Church as a whole, and those have caused a huge stink in particular with Evangelical Fundamentalists.  The Church has historically accepted four important Marian doctrines as orthodox, and those are the following:

1. Mary as the Theotokos, or God-Bearer
2. Mary as Ever-Virgin
3. Mary's bodily Assumption (or Dormition) into heaven upon her repose
4. Mary as part of the Church Expectant, and a prayer partner to those of the Church Militant but not more so than other Saints of the Church.

Roman Catholics correctly believe those along with the rest of the Christian Church (including many of the Reformers - more on that momentarily), and this is not the issue.  The main problem with Roman Catholic views of Mary are the two additional doctrines that they have added as official dogma.   The first of these is the Immaculate Conception, dogmatically defined by Pope Pius IX in 1854.  What this teaches is that Mary, like Jesus, was conceived without sin and some more extreme traditionalists would even maintain she didn't have a natural conception.  This is not accepted by the rest of the Church, and only one Immaculate Conception - that of Jesus Himself - ever occurred.  This almost deifies Mary, and of course this unorthodox viewpoint on the part of the Roman Catholics has caused a lot of issues for them with Fundamentalist Protestants, who use it as a platform to invalidate everything about the Roman Catholic Church, and by default others of us who are not Roman Catholic but still have a sacramental/liturgical Christian faith.  A second Marian doctrinal innovation added by our Roman brethren was the idea of Mary as Mediatrix.  This is a dramatic expansion of the orthodox teaching of Mary's intercessory prayer gifting, in that she is often viewed as aiding in the redemptive process (she is thus also called Co-Redemptrix as well as Mediatrix).   This is not a view that is accepted by the Church at large, in that only Jesus alone can redeem fallen humanity.  The saints and others can intercede for salvation, just like people living in churches do here, but they have no role in the redemptive process.  While Roman Catholics do rightly see Jesus as the only mediator between God and the human race, these particular views of Mary can be problematic.  It would do our Roman Catholic friends well to better define what they are saying, and to have a greater and more clearer affirmation of Jesus as the only Way to God for fallen humanity.

Now, I want to talk about the Reformers.  I wanted to say that much of what the Reformers addressed had little to do with orthodox teachings of the Church - many of the Reformers were actually very orthodox in their views of the correct Marian doctrines, the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, and other things  - but rather what they correctly saw as abuses on the part of the Roman Catholic hierarchy.   The same could be said as well of the Eastern Churches - they were not contesting orthodoxy when they parted ways with the West in 1054, but rather abuses and extravagant claims that Rome made but wasn't entitled to.   Therefore, I say this with extreme love for my Roman Catholic brothers, but it is also going to be some strong medicine to swallow - many of the divisions in Christianity over the past thousand years - in particular the Great Schism and the Reformation - are solely the responsibility of Rome herself.  Had Rome not allowed for abuses, overextension of its authority, and bad politics, the Church may still be organically one today.  Also, the Reformers didn't depart the Catholic faith - many of the extremes of the Fundamentalists today cannot be contributed to the Reformers, but rather to some things their followers began to embrace that began to remove them from a lot of the orthodox teaching of the Church.   Fundamentalists and Emergents are both the result of this, although they appear to be on different spectrums.  Therefore, it is ultimately up to Rome to somehow clarify and redeem itself in order to bring its own teachings back into conformity regarding those areas it has strayed from historic Church teaching, and if it does so, perhaps the Fundamentalists and Emergents will begin to be won back to the Church.  Many Fundamentalists though are actually sincere in their belief, and I have no doubt they are Christian.  And, many Fundamentalists share the same concerns with what is going on in the world now that we as traditional liturgical/sacramental Christians do, but they are gun-shy about seeing it because they wrongly associate the rest of us with the excesses of Roman Catholic distinctives.  We are both Remnant people, but old biases, memories of abuses past, and other issues continue to blind us seeing that.  However, fortunately Jesus Himself knows who is faithful to His teachings, and ultimately when He comes back for His Church He will bring those of us of the Remnant together as one people in Him.  May our prayer be that we prepare ourselves for that in the interim. 

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Liturgical Theology 101 - A Brief Study on Why We Do What We Do as Catholic Christians

I first want to sincerely apologize for my absence this year and not doing as many teachings online - it has been a little crazy working on grad school projects, in particular learning Koine Greek this summer (which you will be seeing me put to use here), so I haven't had as much time to write as I normally do.  Today though, I want to begin a series of articles that will introduce some basic things to you in regard to essential practices of the Anglo-Catholic and other liturgical traditions.

The purpose of the following is twofold.  First, it helps new converts understand the liturgy better.  Second, it will introduce our non-Catholic friends (many of whom are fellow Christians) to liturgy and also clear up some misunderstandings about it they may have.  Some of our Fundamentalist friends, for instance, almost cringe at anything they see that "smacks" of "Roman" to them, but they fail to realize some significant things.  First, although they claim the heritage of the Reformers, they fail in understanding that many of the Reformers didn't have a problem with basic Catholic doctrine to begin with - they protested abuses, not practices.  Therefore, if you read the works of Luther, Calvin, Wesley, and to a lesser extent Zwingli, you will find that all of them believed in Mary being ever-Virgin, and all except Zwingli believed in the Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist.  Many of the significant departures from the sacramental/liturgical tradition you see in contemporary Evangelicalism were not the fault of the Reformers, but rather their later followers.  That being said, it is also interesting to note that our Roman Catholic friends got themselves into a heap of trouble when they tried to explain the Real Presence with the word transubstantiation. The Real Presence should in reality be viewed as a "mystery of faith," meaning that the recipient knows they are receiving Jesus but explanation cannot be offered as for how, because that is not what is important - the important factor is that the communicant has received the Lord, and instead of over-analyzing it one should receive the Eucharist with humility and joy. That being said, let us now begin.

I want to first do a little word study as to how these terms came to be used.  The first is the word liturgy itself.  To put my limited knowledge of Greek to use, the word liturgy comes from two different Greek words, laos meaning "people" and ergon meaning "work."  Combine those with what is called the genitive article (denoting possession), which is in Greek tou, and it creates a word leitourgon.  The meaning of the word then is "the people's work," and it is called that, as Dom Gregory Dix notes in his classic text, On The Shape of the Liturgy, because it is the act of taking part in the solemn corporate worship of God by the "priestly" (in this case, the priesthood of all believers rather than the ordained clergy, although they are part of that) society of Christians (Dom Gregory Dix, On The Shape of the Liturgy {London: A and C Black, 1945} p. 1).  Therefore, what the liturgy is basically consists of corporate works of worship by God's people.  This actually has two Scriptural precedents to it. One is the necessity of corporate worship, as we are admonished in Hebrews 10:25 to not forsake the assembling of ourselves together.  Why?  Because according to both Romans 12:4-5 and I Corinthians 12, we are a Body, not an individual, and one aspect I noted of this from my study of Ephesians is that there are two component relationships to our Christianity - how we relate to God (worship) and how we relate to the Body (fellowship).   The liturgy is both.  It is because of that we now introduce a second term, this one a Latin word, that is often used predominantly in the Western Church to denote the liturgy, and that is the term "Mass."  Mass, of course, comes from the Latin word missae, a verb which means to "collect or assemble."   It actually has a connection to another Greek word, sunago, which means the same thing - it is from the Greek term, as a matter of fact, that we get the term "synagogue."  Thus, we also have the introduction of a Hebraic concept that the Church inherited from Israel, as the synagogue and its tradition was established by the post-exilic Jewish communities in lieu of the Temple being destroyed and the diaspora of the people.  Of course, the center of this is another practice that we as Catholic Christians have called the Eucharist, which of course is the climactic act of the liturgy, and we will talk about that momentarily.  The second Scriptural precedent relates to the two roots of the word "liturgy" in particular, and it is found in James 2:17:  "Thus also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead."  Many of our postmodern, Emergent friends tend to confuse this verse with activism and Christian humanitarianism, which says that in order for a Christian to have vibrant faith they must go out and serve soup at a homeless shelter, etc.  However, as noble and as good as that is, and indeed we should help the less fortunate, those who place that interpretation on this verse miss something - our faith and worship are to be focused on the Lord Jesus Christ, and the verse in discussion is talking about worship, not service.   As a matter of fact, if you don't have true worship, your service is in vain - there are millions of activists who do a lot of good service but are going to hell unless they find the Savior.  Hence, the ultimate act of works as it relates to faith comes from worship of God, both corporately and individually - therefore, regular attendance of the Liturgy and reception of the Eucharist nourish the soul and help us grow. 

That all being said, let us now talk about the central act of the liturgy for Christians, which is the Eucharist.  The term comes from a Greek word meaning "giving thanks," and it denotes primarily the prayer of consecration over the elements, which are transformed into the actual Body and Blood of Jesus which is then partaken of by us as a "mystical Supper," to use an Eastern Church term.  It is the ultimate Thanksgiving feast, because it is a meal that brings true life to the people who receive it.  This too, as Roman Catholic writer Brant Pitre notes, has a Hebraic root to it - it is lifted right out of the Passover, which we do see as an antecedent and allegory of Christ.  Pitre notes that an interesting thing about the original Passover sacrifice was that the Passover lamb was often prepared by skewering the whole carcass - which could not be dismembered or eaten raw or boiled, but had to be fire-roasted - on two rods.  One rod was inserted through the neck area to the tail, and the other through the two front legs, giving it a cruciform shape (interesting!).  This was called in Hebrew a todah, or "thank offering," (Hmmm!) as appreciation for being delivered from death.  And, only members of the covenant community could partake of it (Brant Pitre, Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist {New York: Doubleday, 2011} pp. 56-57).  Now, look at how that relates to the Christian Church.   In Greek, the word paska means "I suffer," and it is used as a cognate of the Hebrew word pesach, which means of course "to pass over."  In the Christian East, as a matter of fact, Easter is still called Paska based on this.  And, it is here that we introduce one of the Latin names for Jesus, the Agnus Dei, meaning the "Lamb of God."  The Agnus Dei is also a part of the traditional Western Liturgies, and is often chanted just before the Eucharist is received with the Latin words "Agnus Dei, que tollis peccata Mundi, miserari Nobis."  The ancient form of this, still used in traditional Latin Roman Masses, is a beautiful hymn in adoration of Jesus as the Lamb of God, slain for the sins of the world.   At the end of the reception of the Eucharist, a prayer is often said in thanksgiving by all traditions of the Christian Church which in essence expresses thanks to God for partaking of the "mystical Supper" (meaning of course that we received something much more significant than mere bread and wine - it is the Body and Blood of our Lord!), and that we may take what we have received and witness that to the world around us.  Now, as Pitre noted about the original Passover only being partaken by those of covenant community, so it is with the Eucharist as well.  I once heard a professor at a Pentecostal college flippantly say that he would give the Eucharist to all, both saved and unsaved, and I was flabbergasted at how crass that was from a supposedly educated man who knows the Bible.  The Eucharist is not an open meal for just anyone to partake - it must be taken in covenant, meaning that in a Christian context, only one who has been validly baptized, sealed (by the sacrament of Chrismation/Confirmation - more on that in another study), and also believes that what they are receiving is the Body and Blood of our Lord can partake of it - serious consequences await those who violate that basic teaching.  That, unfortunately, is a huge downfall of much of the postmodern church however - in their careless disregard and deconstruction of Christian theology, people who are Emergent bastardize the sacramental aspects of our faith, oftentimes having the twin result of reinforcing Fundamentalist prejudices and also giving those of us who know better headaches over the misappropriation of something holy.  Many of these Emergents often do start out with a sincere desire to have a more vibrant spirituality, but then they get careless with sacred things and end up mixing them with mysticism and esoteric understandings of Christian spirituality that are contradictory to both Scripture and sacred Tradition.  Then, it is up to those of us who know our faith to straighten out the mess these people create, and that can be a challenge.  Let us take a few moments to address that, as it signifies perfectly what liturgy and the Eucharist are not.

I have watched and read some wonderful material by some capable apologists - many Reformed Evangelicals - who do expose a lot of the dangers of Emergent Christianity and its apostasy. People like Elliot Netsch, Warren Smith, and James Sungenis do a great service to Christianity as a whole with sounding the alarm regarding these trends.  However, they are also coming from a Reformed perspective, and often let their own bias cause them to target this as being some sort of "Catholic aberration" or something.  Therefore, some misrepresentations of the Desert Fathers have been appropriated by the Emergent crowd, and their critics then assume that the Desert Fathers taught mysticism and heresies.  Let me straighten that out now - first, if the Desert Fathers were alive today, they would be turning over in their graves at what people like Brian McLaren and Rob "No Hell" Bell are doing in their name.   The Desert Fathers were completely orthodox in doctrine, and they never wrote or said that any practices they had were binding or normative for all Christians - as a matter of fact, it could be argued that many of these Fathers were so sincere in their faith that they would do almost anything to be closer to Jesus, and there is nothing wrong with that at all.  Emergents today are not necessarily doing that - they are redefining and deconstructing Christianity in order to remake it in their own image, and that is not something any Patristic writer, Desert Father or otherwise, would tolerate.  I am not going to spend much more time on this other than to say that perhaps some of our Reformed Evangelical friends would do well to "study to show themselves approved," without lumping Emergent Church people in with traditionalist Catholic Christians based on some Romophobic biases that they themselves need to overcome.  It is time that many of our Reformed Evangelical friends realize that we who are traditionalists are on the same side, and we share the same concerns, but nothing will be accomplished by a flippant dismissal of liturgical/sacramental theology based on some bastardizations by Emerging Church people.  In the future, I want to actually write something addressing that more in detail, but now we should get back to the subject at hand.

 We have talked about the basic Scriptural and linguistic roots and background of liturgy, so now let us address how liturgy came to be as it is.  Our Evangelical friends will often reason that if "liturgy" means "the people's work," then why all the ceremony?  The Emergents and other postmoderns do the same thing, but then they revise things to such a degree that "liturgy" for them becomes mere social activism. Both cases are wrong.  The liturgy, as most of us celebrate it as Catholic Christians, has its roots in Hebraic worship, and indeed it does not take much to see the continuity between the way we "do" liturgy and the worship of the ancient Temple - I would argue that the Temple was both a picture of the throne room in heaven as well as a foreshadow of the Church.  And, being many of the earliest Christians were themselves Jewish, they appropriated the worship they knew - which was Biblical - into the worship of the Church.  Therefore, as early as the first century AD, we have already a basic liturgical form, and essentially it consisted of two parts.  The first part is called usually the Liturgy of the Word, and in that the lessons from Scripture are read and expounded by the minister, and there is a confession of sin, prayers for those in need, etc.  In an ancient document called the Didache, it spells out the rhyme and reason for this simply - in order to prepare for the receiving of the Eucharist, one had to be instructed in the Word and also be reconciled to God and to each other as a Body.  Here is what it says in regard to that:

And on the Lord's own day gather yourselves together to break bread and give thanks, first confessing your transgressions that your sacrifice may be pure.  And let no man, having his dispute with his fellow, join your assembly until they have been reconciled, that your sacrifice may not be defiled. (http://www.annomundi.com/bible/didache.pdf, accessed 6/19/2013)

In other words, there again is the earliest confirmation that not just anyone could receive the Eucharist, which is probably why the liturgy was called a "work," because it took some effort to prepare for it!  At the conclusion of the first part of the liturgy, the catechumens (those who had not yet been baptized) and the unbelievers were dismissed, but not without a sort of "altar call," if you will.  The best preserved example of this can be found in the American 1928 Book of Common Prayer in a section of the liturgy called "the Comfortable Words," and here is the excerpt of that:

Hear what comfortable words our Savior Christ saith unto all who truly turn to Him.  Come unto me, all ye that are heavy laden, and I will refresh you (Matthew 11:28).  So God loved the world, that He gave his only-begotten Son, to the end that all that believe in him should not perish, but have everlasting life (John 3:16).
Hear also what Saint Paul saith.  This is a true saying, and worthy of all men to be received, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners (I Timothy 1:15).
Hear also what Saint John saith.  If any man sin, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the Righteous, and He is the propitiation for our sins (1 John 2:1-2)
(The Book of Common Prayer, In the English Parochial Tradition, According to Orthodox Catholic Usage {Glendale, CO: Lancelot Andrewes Press, 2009} p. 495)

This traditional Anglican part of the Liturgy was more than likely also used by John Wesley, a committed and devout Anglo-Catholic, as part of an altar call during his meetings in the Great Awakening.  Its purpose in the liturgy at this point was evangelical - it proclaimed the Gospel to the unconverted who may be in the church, but it also served to instruct the catechumens before they were dismissed.  After this point, the catechumens are dismissed, and they receive instruction in the faith from that point.  And, it starts the second part of the Liturgy, known as the Communion of the Faithful.

The first part of this section of the liturgy begins with what is called the Sanctus - "Holy, Holy, Holy Lord God of Sabaoth. Heaven and Earth are filled with Thy Glory, Glory be to Thee oh Lord most High. Blessed is He who cometh in the name of the Lord, Hosanna in the Highest!"    This hearkens back to both to the vision in Isaiah 6, but also to St. John the Revelator's vision in Revelation 4:8.  With the ringing of bells, it signifies that we as believers are about to enter into one of the holiest parts of worship - the presence of the Lord Himself, in this case the Eucharist.  We are to approach this with great humility - none of us are worthy to receive it except through the Blood of Jesus, and we are reminded of that by the Sanctus, which tells us whose presence we are in and that we need to show the proper respect, if you will.  It is also a picture of the heavenly worship we will one day, provided we remain faithful to the Lord, experience.  In the Christian East, we see this more dramatically, as the iconography, the vestments of the clergy and lay ministers, etc., reflect the worship of the heavenly temple.  From the Sanctus, the elements of bread and wine are consecrated by the celebrating priest, and at the point of consecration, they become Jesus Himself.  There are two dramatic ways that consecration is noted.  In the Christian East, the priest will often simulate with his hands the flapping of a dove's wings, symbolizing the descent of the Holy Spirit and the presence of Jesus coming to the Eucharistic species.  In the Anglican tradition, it is symbolized by the ringing of a bell thrice, drawing the worshipper's attention to the fact something important is happening - the King has come!  There is an eschatological dimension to this as well, which Scott Hahn elaborates more upon in his excellent book The Lamb's Supper (New York: Random House, 1999), but to simplify it's this - the liturgy, and the Eucharist, give us a picture of the Second Coming of Christ, and in doing so, it can be looked at as a "dress rehearsal" for when the King returns for us one day.   This is the same thing that Gospel legend Bill Gaither sought to capture in his classic song, "The King Is Coming," and indeed, I would not be opposed for using this (in particular the Pfeifers' rendition of it - wow!) as a Communion hymn.   This Eucharistic consecration is the pinnacle of the liturgy, and the central focus of the liturgy is placed where it should be at this point - on Jesus.  And, Jesus then comes to each of us when we receive the Eucharist - it is a reaffirmation that He is in us, and we are in Him.  Understanding it this way, I cannot fathom anymore worship without the Eucharist - Jesus becomes really present to me personally in a tangible way, and with that presence also comes healing, cleansing from sin, and spiritual life.   So, is Jesus really present in the Eucharist?  You better believe it!  But, beware - there are dire warnings in Scripture about taking this Holy Supper unworthily, and for those that do, God help them literally!  That is why the good professor's remarks about just giving it to anybody were so disturbing - it is not for just anyone, but rather those who are called, baptized, and sealed by His Spirit. 

As can be seen, the Eucharist and liturgy are often used interchangeably, but they are not quite the same - rather, they are intimately connected to each other.   And, although more could be said, this will give you a basic understanding of liturgical theology, and I hope that those of you who feel the need to pursue a deeper walk in your Christianity, perhaps this is something you should start to consider and study more.  However, don't just assume that because you are already a Christian that it automatically qualifies you to receive the Eucharist - there is much more to it than that.  For one thing, you need to receive the full sacraments of initiation - including Confirmation/Chrismation - to be fully part of the Church.  And, they must be received at the hand of a validly-ordained minister - we take Apostolic authority seriously in our churches, and this must be understood before anyone can receive.  It sounds exclusive, and no offense to other Christians is intended at all - getting into heaven here is not the issue, but rather a fuller communion of faith with the Church Christ has established.  Many have been saved by Jesus, and baptized, but they lack the fullness of the Church and its communion, which is what this is all about.  So, for those of you who may not be Chrismated into the Church, you are always welcome, but just remember to understand that you will not be able to fully partake in the sacramental life of the Church until you understand her authority Christ has given her.  God bless until next time.







Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Christians and Other Religions - a Primer

Being in graduate school has been a challenge, and after a course entitled "Christianity and World Religions" recently it has compelled me to address this issue from a more orthodox approach than some of the textbook material we have read.  As I relate what I am talking about tonight, it is important to remember that we who are Christians have the fullness of truth in Jesus Christ, and our salvation is based on the Scripture in John 14:6 - Jesus Christ is the only way of salvation, case closed!

What is our response to other religions as Christians, especially in a more pluralistic culture that we live in today?  To begin, it must be remembered that there are people we do have spiritual fellowship with, and others to whom we relate civilly.   That being said, let's talk.

Christians are in a position to where we have the fullness of truth (as Catholic Christians, we have even more than that - the fullness of salvation in the Church), and since we do have that endowed to us, it is not up for debate or negotiation.   However, on a grassroots level, it is entirely possible to get along with, befriend, and respect others of different religious backgrounds, and indeed our greatest witness to those people is showing them that we do respect them without giving full agreement to their belief systems.  Being almost 20 years in the corporate world, I have worked with all types of people - neo-pagans, Sikhs, Muslims, Hindus, Jains, and others - and for the most part I found them to be kind, courteous, and decent people.  On a grassroots level, we can and should talk to and get to know people like this, while at the same time finding that "bridge" to share our faith and the Gospel with them.  The problem arises when ambiguous language, often spouted from the mouths of ecclesiastical bureaucrats, haughty professors, and verbose theologians and academics of other disciplines, tries to reduce this dialogue into a formula - then you get into trouble!  The textbook we are using in the class for instance, written by a Pentecostal scholar by the name of Veli-Matti Karkainnen entitled An Introduction to the Theology of Religions, paints the Vatican II documents, the theologies of St. Irenaeus, Wesley, and the Anabaptists, and others, as being almost universalistic.  And, what is worse is that many of my fellow classmates, who are a generation younger than I am, buy into it.  Yet, when I read what these great leaders of the faith wrote, I didn't see an embrace of other religions at all, and as a matter of fact, it was Karkainnen who gave them that interpretation rather than they themselves.   But, it gets more bizarre - another book we used, John Kaltner's Introducing the Quran, basically paints the Muslim book as being some great text of pacifism, equality, and tolerance - it is obvious to me that Mr. Kaltner has no sense of history whatsoever, and that is disconcerting when this book is being used at a supposedly Christian university as part of a Theological Studies program.   Yet, younger kids (I call them kids, as my classmates are a good 20 years younger than me for the most part) swallow that crap hook, line, and sinker!  What material like that proves to me is that political correctness is even re-defining theology, and that cannot be tolerated by anyone who loves the Lord and stands for His truth.   And, that is why I am writing this now. 

To begin with, yes, some teachings of other religions have merit as far as they don't contradict Scripture, but a little truth here and there doesn't resolve the fact that these religions as a whole are still false.  The virtues and other things in non-Christian religions that are true are things that verify that at one time, six thousand years ago in the past, God created the heavens and the earth, and all that is within them.  Then, four thousand years ago a flood came, and Noah and his family were spared to repopulate the earth.  But, sin entered the world when Adam bit into that apple, pomegranate, or whatever that fruit was from the Tree of Knowledge, and Satan's lie is that man could become God.  Sure enough, a few short centuries after the Flood, Noah's descendants sought to build a tower, and God said "NO!" and scattered them.  Did all these people know something about God?  Yes, they did!  And, did not God create them, endowing them with a nature that carried some sense of ethical discernment?  Yes, He did!  Therefore, when a Jain values integrity in business dealings, or a Buddhist has respect for life, not to mention that some things such as sexual sin, over-indulgence, and murder are still universally taboo, it just means that some vestige of that original truth, of which the Judeo-Christian tradition possesses the fullness, exists in those people.  And, indeed, those virtues can be used to reach these people!  However, over the many millennia since Babel, as populations dispersed, a lot of error, mythology, and demonic revelation got mixed into the mindsets of these same people, and although they started off asking the right questions, they ended up at the wrong answer, thanks in part to Satan and his deception.  Many scholars these days criticize missionaries of the past - scholar Allan Anderson, a reader in Pentecostal Studies at the University of Birmingham in the UK, is one of them - by saying they were "racist" or "ignorant" because they saw the demonic forces behind pagan idols, and with their own eyes many of those dedicated missionaries were on the front lines battling very real manifestations of the demonic and knew what they were encountering.  Yet, political correctness has infiltrated theology, and people like Allan Anderson are actually sanctifying demonic bondage by saying that "no religions are evil," and that demons are a figment of a vivid imagination - people like Anderson have even gone as far as to call missionaries "liars" with "exaggeration to pull heart strings and purse straps" despite the fact that many of those same missionaries have reached more people for Christ than many Ivory-Tower scholastics ever will.  That being said, let me give my theory as to the origins of these religions.

Back in the day, after the Fall of man in the Garden, some fallen angels saw the "daughters of men" and lusted after them - they procreated with those girls and birthed a race of quasi-human beings of large stature called later the Nephilim.  Due to the origins of these creatures, they could not be redeemed, and ultimately their creation was a plan of Satan to thwart God's plan.  When the Nephilim died, their disembodied spirits became demons, which means the latter are not fallen angels, but rather the seed of fallen angels.   Genesis records that these Nephilim were giants, and "mighty men of renown," and to me that would speak of the mythologies of the half-god/half-human figures such as Gilgamesh (some believed him to be synonymous with Nimrod, incidentally) and Hercules - yes, I am saying these mythological figures had a basis in fact, and that they were real persons!  Two things happened after their days ended though.  The first was a series of legends that evolved into an elaborate mythology, and the second was the deification of demonic spirits as gods by different civilizations.  And, that is the origin of every other religion except Judaism and Christianity (except maybe Zoroastrians, Mandaeans, and the Confucians in China - the latter is more a civic philosophy than a religion anyway).  It is therefore my belief that behind every pagan idol is a demonic presence being worshipped (hence also the hideous appearances of some of the idols too!), and the head deity of a religious system may well be one of those "powers and principalities" it talks about in Ephesians 6.  This does not mean that all the followers of a religion are possessed themselves by demons, not at all - they may not even be totally devoted to all the practices of a given religion and may be nominal and thus more secularized anyway - but it does mean that the teachings of that religion are the "doctrines of devils" it speaks of in II Timothy.  Therefore, in this age of "political correctness" where the supernatural is often pooh-poohed by supposedly "Christian" scholarship as being fabrication and superstition, it is important to see past all the crap and instead know God's Word and the truth it contains, as well as the testimony of the Church throughout the ages, which would concur with what I have just said in many instances.   I will probably be the object of some ridicule by the supposedly "enlightened," but there are two things I am sure of.  First, I know what the testimony of the whole Church is.  Second, many of these self-appointed "intelligentsia" are themselves called by the Bible fools, because they have exalted their own wisdom to a form of idolatry.  Therefore, let them continue in their folly - I only smile pleasantly at them and say "you'll see one day."  Unfortunately, for some of them it may be too late. 

A lot more could be said on this subject, but we'll conclude for now as I am somewhat exhausted from such a hectic schedule in recent months.   God be with each who reads this, and see you next time.

Farewell

 In January 2010, I started Sacramental Present Truths as a platform for my own reflections and teachings on Biblical and theological issues...